In the ever-evolving landscape of technology and digital giants, behind-the-scenes manoeuvres and strategic discussions often remain hidden from the public eye. However, a recent development in the ongoing Google antitrust case has provided a rare glimpse into Apple’s considerations regarding its search engine partners. Unsealed testimonies from the trial have revealed that Apple contemplated replacing Google’s search engine with Microsoft’s Bing or privacy-focused DuckDuckGo across its devices. Let’s delve into this intriguing revelation and its implications.

The Background: Google’s Dominance and the Antitrust Case

The Department of Justice (DOJ) has accused Google of abusing its search market dominance, and a key aspect of this case revolves around the revenue-sharing deal between Google and Apple. Google pays Apple billions annually to remain the default search engine on Apple devices, making it a lucrative partnership. But behind the scenes, Apple was exploring alternative options.

Bing Acquisition: Apple’s Evaluation

One of the eye-opening revelations from the testimonies was Apple’s consideration of acquiring Microsoft’s Bing or forming a joint venture with the tech giant. Apple’s Senior Vice President, John Giannandrea, testified that discussions with Microsoft occurred in 2018 and again in 2020.

These conversations were part of Apple’s internal evaluation process, which aimed to compare the quality of Bing’s search results with Google’s. While Bing performed worse overall, it matched Google in desktop English searches. Interestingly, Apple had previously used Bing as the default search service for some of its products, including Siri and Spotlight searches, from 2013 to 2017.

However, Apple ultimately decided to stick with Google, a partnership estimated to bring in around $19 billion annually. Internal emails revealed during the trial suggested that Apple might have been using Bing as a negotiation tactic to extract more money from Google, as confirmed by Mikhail Parakhin, Microsoft’s chief of advertising and web services during his testimony.

DuckDuckGo: The Privacy-Focused Alternative

In addition to Bing, Apple held numerous meetings and phone calls with DuckDuckGo, a privacy-focused search engine. The discussions centred on the possibility of making DuckDuckGo the default search engine for Safari’s private browsing mode. DuckDuckGo CEO Gabriel Weinberg confirmed these talks during his testimony.

Despite these discussions and DuckDuckGo’s successful integration of some of its privacy technologies into Safari, Giannandrea denied any serious consideration of replacing Google with DuckDuckGo. He expressed concerns about DuckDuckGo’s reliance on Bing for search information, fearing it could compromise user privacy.

Revealing Industry Secrets

The unsealing of these testimonies has provided a rare glimpse into the strategic manoeuvring within an industry primarily dominated by Google. It highlights why few tech giants have seriously attempted to compete with Google in the search sector.

The ongoing antitrust case against Google is the DOJ’s first against a major tech company in over two decades. The release of these testimonies, following widespread criticism of the trial’s secrecy, marks a significant turning point in the trial’s transparency.

In conclusion, Apple’s contemplation of Bing and DuckDuckGo as potential alternatives to Google’s search engine highlights the complex dynamics of the tech industry. While Google’s dominance in the search market remains unchallenged, it’s clear that even giants like Apple have explored alternative options. As the Google antitrust case unfolds, we can expect more revelations that provide insight into the inner workings of tech giants and their partnerships.

Do you want to make sure your business stays on top of its marketing efforts?  Our team at the number one Essex SEO Agency may be able to help.